I wrote this rant originally for the Witchhaven mailing list. Yes, it's humor, and in a way it's also not. I do feel very strongly that the Craft ought to be treated better than this:
Recently something that sparked a discussion was using Cthulu deities in a Wiccan format. As it happens, there is a guy who each year at minicon puts up posters advertising "Cthulu Wicca". Though I was offended at seeing them, my friends assured me that it was just a joke; and taken the right way, I admit itís a pretty hilarious one.
Some of the people on the mailing list didn't seem to see it that way, and started listing off entity names they had used in ritual and asking for source material. I like to think I'm a creative person, but I really don't see how the Wicca and the Cthulu mythos can be reasonably combined.
What I know of the Cthulu mythos comes from three places; 1-AD&D's first edition of the "Deities and Demigods" book, which contained an unauthorized gaming usage of the Cthulu mythos; 2-The Call of Cthulu Role Playing Game, which was an authorized version, and 3-the stories of H. P. Lovecraft, which were the inspiration for it all in the first place. The mythos itself is presented as being so alien as to 1-be completely evil in effects and 2-eventually kill, mutate or drive insane any who come into connection with it. The first is presented as the most desirable, and the three are not mutually exclusive.
Wicca, as I have studied, understand and practice it, acknowledges and respects the reality of God and Goddess and magick, and develops a real and personal connection with the deities. For someone to be willing to combine the two, seems to me to imply only a few possible attitudes.
Wicca is real, but Cthulu is not: This would be a person who wanted a real relationship with the divine, and used names from the Cthulu pantheon for some weird reason. This seems disrespectful to one's path in the extreme; why use Wicca to have a relationship with a God that isn't really there. If this person isn't taking Wicca seriously enough to want to experience connection with real deity (and not what they have made up or redefined as convenient) they why do it at all? This is the sort of person who calls Kali a "Mother Goddess" and doesnít know what a thugee was. Is.
Cthulu is real, but Wicca is not: This is a person who likes the idea of playing around with dangerous powers, but since there is no real, contact, thinks they run no risk. This is either not a spiritual person at all, or somebody on a path that is really not working for them. If someone doesn't take their deities seriously enough to seek connection with them, then how and more importantly why relate to them at all? This is the sort of person who would have a coronary if an attempt to channel deity actually worked.
Both are fake: This is the goth-chick (or guy) who likes to play with a spooky path, and spooky deity names, but doesn't take any of it seriously. I wouldn't be surprised at this person having chosen Wicca to be able to say "ooh I'm a *witch*", and having chosen Cthulu to be able to brag about how gory their gods are. This is similar to the person who says "I'm a Satanist" and when pressed, admits that they don't really worship or believe in Satan, they just want to irritate fundamentalist Christians.
Both are real: this is a person who is insane or suicidal, or aiming for both on some level.
Then there is the 'I don't know' factor: This is a newbie being led into this by someone else who tells them that all the horrific lore is really there to keep the "wrong people" from learning the "real secrets". This person is a fool, or severely unfortunate in choice of mentors. Perhaps there is some respectful, serious person out there who is working with "Cthulu Wicca". I havenít met or heard of them; and Iím not sure I would want to. In fact, Iím pretty sure I would not want to.
So just in case, consider this a warning from all those who found out the truth too late, and are now in no condition to express how very wrong and foolish they were......